• Baron Von J@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    2 months ago

    Only if you assume their vote is owed to some candidate instead of earned.

    It’s just math. There is no state where a 3rd party presidential candidate will win.

    You cannot assume the default is voting for the candidate YOU like

    I don’t. That’s why I used non-partisan words and didn’t name any candidates.

    and that any deviation from that is ‘taking votes away’ from someone who never earned them it the first place

    I never said that you’re taking votes away from a candidate. I said a vote for a third party is reducing the number of votes that one of the major party candidates needs to receive in order to win. The winner is the one who receives the most votes, and that is going to be either the Democratic or Republican nominee (show me a poll that shows any 3rd party candidate leading either of the major party candidates in any state if you disagree). A vote for any other candidate just lowers the total number of votes either of them needs in order to win.

    I should have clarified, though, that I’m speaking of states where there is no RCV.